Translate

Sunday, April 16, 2017

Learning Multiple Languages—Help or Hindrance?

I have always believed that you can't be too thin, too rich, or know too many languages.  So it was a shock to me recently when my Italian instructor advised me otherwise.  Here is what happened.

It was the first day of Italian class, a mixed level class, so the instructor asked how many of us were Italian language beginners.  I raised my hand and added that I already spoke Spanish and Portuguese, which I thought would move me out of the novice category.  Imagine my surprise when she said, "Forget everything you know about those languages for this class." What??? Not only was my ego bruised, but I think she was dead wrong!

One of the reasons I chose to enroll in Italian class is that Italian is a member of the Romance family of languages, that is, languages derived from Latin.




Italian was the only major Romance language that I haven't studied yet. Surely I had somewhat of a head start with this new language?

The first challenge was to attune my ear to three of the unique sounds of Italian.  One of the main sound differences between Italian and Spanish is the Italian "c" in "ce" and "ci," which is pronounced like the English "ch" sound. In Spanish, the same "c" has an English "s" sound. For example, the word "cena" (supper) means "supper" in both languages, but the beginning sound is slightly different. Try saying it!  Not hard, just hard to remember at times.  Also, Italian "s" between vowels is an English "z" sound, which is different from Spanish, but the same as Portuguese.  Try saying "casa" in Italian.

Another major sound difference in Italian and Spanish is the frequent use of double consonants in Italian, which require a longer sound.  My cat, Bitsy, is a "gata" in Spanish, but in Italian, she is a "gatta."  I think those double consonants give Italian a special rhythm.  But the other Italian consonants and vowels are familiar to me from other Romance languages. (I'm contrasting my struggles to understand and speak Irish Gaelic, which I have been studying for about two years now!)

On to Italian vocabulary. Over 80% of words in Italian and Spanish are similar.  What a blessing.  I should be able to read and at least make a good guess at the majority of Italian words right now.  If you know Spanish, see if you can guess the meaning of these Italian words:  uno, spagnola, amico, macchina, musica, farmacia, contenta, importante, bene, casa.  (Uno, española, amigo, máquina, música, farmacia, contenta, importante, bien, casa.)  Fàcile, no?


My enthusiasm  may diminish when I hit Italian morphology and syntax (in other words, GRAMMAR). Italian has three possible words for "the" before masculine nouns — "il," "lo," and "l'," depending on the following sound.  Spanish has basically one word— "el."  Italian words change from singular to plural by changing the ending vowel sounds, for example, "il libro" (the book), "i libri" (the books).  Spanish makes plurals by adding "s" or "es." Italian verbs follow a typical verb paradigm for conjugation, but of course the endings for each subject must be memorized.


So does studying multiple languages act as a help or hindrance in language acquisition?  I  vote for help.  But I can see that I am going to have to assign a portion of my brain solely to Italian so that I won't mix up the Romance languages.

Maybe I'll just dream about renting a villa in the Italian countryside to enjoy with friends and family, and Italian will find a permanent place in my soul.












Thursday, March 30, 2017

Preparing my ears for a trip to Ireland



Six weeks from now, I will be in Dublin, Ireland with my husband, Wayne, beginning a two-week tour of our own devising.  The long weekend we spent in Dublin several years ago only whetted our appetites for more.  Wayne fell in love with Eggs Benedict at Wynn's Hotel in central Dublin, and I fell in love with Irish English, so pleasing to the ear.

For this trip, I wanted to prepare myself a little better linguistically.  Google provided multiple sites with lists of Irish vocabulary and expressions.  Many were slang expressions, which we probably won't be hearing or using, but I wanted to focus on a few useful terms to help in our travels around Ireland.






As I read through the lists, I was surprised to find expressions I had heard growing up in a family with Southern roots.  These expressions didn't sound foreign to me at all!

"This dinner is taking ages."  (a long time)
"rare as hen's teeth" (very hard to find)
"doing the washing" (laundry)
"Who all's there?"  (Who is present?)
"conked out" (car stalls or stops suddenly)
"poormouthing" (lamenting lack of money when you actually have plenty)
"belly up" (unsuccessful)

Other Irish English words and expressions were familiar from our travels to the United Kingdom.  All I needed was a review.  We will be renting a car in Ireland, so  "boot" (trunk) and "petrol" (gasoline) are good words to remember.  Potato chips are "crisps," and French fries are "chips."  (An essential food group!)  A fish and chips shop is a "chipper" or a "chippie."    I will need to take a "jumper" (sweater) for the chillier Irish May weather. A"Yank" is an American, from anywhere in the U.S.

Eventually though, I began discovering Irish-English terms that are new to me and that will be useful on our trip.  Very important, of course, is how to locate the restrooms.  In Ireland, one says "toilet" or "jacks."  The doors are marked "fir jacks" (men) and "ban jacks" (women). And let's hope we don't have anything but pleasant relations with the "garda" or "guards" ( Irish policemen).

I'll have to remember that "dinner" refers to "lunch" when making plans for meals.  And that "mineral" is another word for "soft drink."   Also, "sambo" is a sandwich.  If I am in a store, the shopkeeper may greet me with "now."  And I may need to recognize a slang word for euro, "yoyo."  I understand that "cat' may be used to describe something bad or terrible, which I will take great exception to out of respect for Bitsy, our house cat, and her five feral cousins outdoors. Finally, if a lodging is described as "homely," I will know that it is homey and cozy, not ugly!

Finally,  two words kept coming up in every Irish language site I visited, "sláinte" and "craic."  The first is a toast, "to your health," and the second refers to fun or good times.  I found several different pronunciations for "sláinte," so I plan to listen very closely to fellow patrons on pub visits.




The pronunciation of "craic" is close enough to English "crack" to give unsuspecting tourists a start.

Needless to say, I'll be doing field work on Irish English and taking copious linguistic notes to write a follow up blog in May.  That is, if I can find time amongst all the "craic"  I hope to have in Ireland.





Thursday, March 16, 2017

Why is language learning so slow?



Have you ever started language study with great enthusiasm and then dropped it?  I'll bet most of us have, with resulting guilt feelings .  Starting on the journey to learn a new language is one of my life's greatest pleasures.  I dream of a new system of communication, a fascinating vocabulary, and even the possibility of traveling to an unknown country.  But it doesn't take long for euphoria to disappear and reality to set in.

I recently enrolled in a once a week, twelve-week Italian class at a local learning institute.




Italian wasn't on my bucket list of languages to learn, but it was the only foreign language course offered this term.  Having a solid background in other Romance languages, I hoped that Italian would come fairly easily and that I could make quick progress.  Wrong!

Today's class is mid-way in the course, a good time to take stock in what I have learned in the Italian language so far. 

 I am becoming acquainted with the Italian sound system.  It took a while to remember that "ce" and "ci" require a beginning sound like "church."  Similarly, "g' takes on the beginning sound of  "judge" before "e" and "i."  Italian has double consonants that have a longer sound than a single consonant (compare Italian for "cup," tazza  with Spanish tasa).  The rhythm and intonation of Italian are also starting to become distinctive to me.

The structure of Italian gives me a comfortable feeling. It is an SVO (subject, verb, object) language, with verbs requiring agreement with subjects and adjectives requiring agreement with nouns. I'm sure some idiosyncratic grammatical features will pop up with time, but they will be intriguing rather than incomprehensible.  I can read simple Italian already.  

The vocabulary of Italian is proving to be more elusive than I would have imagined.  I forgot to take into account the confusion that studying several Romance languages at the same time may bring.  Am I saying a word in Italian, or is it Spanish or Portuguese or even French?  My Italian language study has not progressed enough to say with confidence!

And can I understand spoken Italian?  Not very much!  My husband, Wayne, and I were watching an old WWII movie recently where the action took place in Italy.  A Walk in the Sun was the title. Quite a bit of Italian was spoken (with no subtitles), and I know Wayne expected me to be able to translate.  All I could understand was a random word or two. (I guess I should have lied and made up a credible translation!)

Language acquisition is a relic in the modern world of lightning fast knowledge through technology. So much of the world comes to us so quickly.  We expect language learning to happen overnight. After all, if we need to know how to do almost anything, can't we just google it? 

Barring the unlikely circumstances that I will be spending a year in Italy or becoming best friends with a chatty Italian, I had better resign myself to the slow road to Italian.  Maybe I should stop worrying and just enjoy the journey?







Wednesday, March 1, 2017

First Steps in Romanian

I am such a sucker for new language offerings on Duolingo, my favorite online language learning program.  Romanian is the latest language that has caught my attention and set me daydreaming about a different country and a new culture.



A quick Internet search located the country of Romania in Eastern Europe.





24 million people speak Romanian as a native language and four million more as a second language. Romanian is the only Romance language currently spoken in an area where Slavic languages dominate. The European Union lists Romanian as one of its official languages.  And if this were not enough enticement, the infamous Dracula is a product of Romanian folk legends. (I may not be reading these!)

Dracula's Castle?


First, a word to naysayers who are not quite as addicted to language study as I am.  Why Romanian, they may ask?  The appeal for me was that Romanian is one of the principal Romance languages (along with Catalan, French, Italian, Portuguese, and Spanish). I practice four of them (minus Catalan) on a daily basis on Duolingo.  The lure of learning a new language for which I have somewhat of a head start was too much to resist.

In the introductory Romanian lessons, I looked for familiar vocabulary words.  Hmm.  Not as familiar as I would have preferred!  The word for juice, suc reminded me of suco  in Portuguese; the word for bread, păine, looked like pain in French; cafea (coffee) was close to English; femeie (woman) looks like female in English.  Many of the other words, bărbat (man), băiat (boy) and copil (child) will require more attention. 

I am making baby steps in Romanian at present, perhaps because the beta version currently available on Duolingo is only a web version.  The other languages I study can be done on the fly with the Duolingo app on a mobile device.. 

But I have started using a comparison/contrast technique to determine how to say "a, "an" and "the" in Romanian. You may be smiling at the elementary nature of this grammar point.  But the ability to use indefinite and definite articles is a common starting point in language learning.  (After all, is the meaning of "an apple" the same as "the apple"?)

Here are some patterns I discovered:

un copil - a child
copilul - the child

o cafea - a coffee
cafeaua - the coffee

un măr - an apple
marul - the apple

un băiat - a boy
băiatul - the boy

o femeie - a woman
femeia - the woman


So what can I hypothesize from these few examples?

-The translations for a, an in Romanian are un and o, perhaps un for masculine nouns and o for feminine nouns?
-The definite article (the) in Romanian appears in a surprising position - attached to the end of the noun as a suffix.
- The definite article suffix takes several forms:  -ul; -a; and -ua.
- Sometimes the letter "a" carries a diacritic and is written ă.  Does the diacritic indicate a change in pronunciation or some other feature?

I have more questions than answers at this point. 



Are Romanian nouns classified by gender, and if so, are the genders masculine and feminine as in other Romance languages? What is the determining factor in the form of the definite article?  I have discovered three up to now. What's with the "ă"?  (It took me a while to locate the symbol to type. Now I want to know more about it.) 

The Romanian language has an intrinsic appeal for me.  Who knows why?  Some languages do, and others don't.  I'm looking forward to making many more discoveries in Romanian as my fifth Romance language.  


Wednesday, February 8, 2017

More about using patterns to acquire languages

Patterns
Can a language learner acquire another language more successfully by delaying grammar study? That is the question I have been exploring in recent blog posts using examples from various languages. I wish I had a definitive answer for the world!

Traditionalists insist on a heavy dose of the study of structure before a learner begins to communicate in a new language.  Innovators insist that grammar is best acquired gradually, as the learner is using the language.  And many language educators ride the fence, debating how much grammar study to require and at what stage.

I have been trying to test the theory that calls for less explicit grammar study in my studies using the online language program Duolingo. Grammar explanations are included in the program if you choose to use them.  But I have been scrupulously avoiding the explanations, trying instead to formulate and test rules by observing patterns for a new language.

Have I been tempted to sneak a peak at a verb conjugation or an explanation of word order?  Of course. I am after all only human!  But I have tried to develop what the linguist Stephen Krashen has labeled a "tolerance for ambiguity" and not insist on immediate answers to my grammar problems. Searching for patterns in language has been a big help.  Here is what I discovered recently about the Welsh language, which, by the way, I find charming.



Dw i'n hoffi coffi.  I like coffee.
Dw i'n hoffi Owen.  I like Owen.
Dw i'n yfed cwrw.  I drink beer.
Dw i'n hoffi yfed cwrw.  I like to drink beer.

Several Welsh grammar points can be hypothesized from these sentences. To talk about oneself, begin the sentence with dw i'n.  The verb follows, hoffi (like) and yfed (drink).  The direct object completes the sentence, coffi (coffee), Owen (Owen) , and cwrw (beer).

The word order in Welsh, at least for declarative sentences at this point, appears to mirror English with subject first, then verb, then object.  (This is a relief from another Gaelic language I have been studying, Irish, which puts the verb first in the sentence.) Any similarity between the new language and one's native language is one less thing to think about.

Once your mind has absorbed these grammar facts, other questions begin to arise.  How do you make a sentence negative in case you really don't like something?  How can you ask another person if they like something so you can exchange information in a conversation?

Dw i ddim yn hoffi bacwn.  I do not like bacon.  So the i'n of the affirmative Welsh sentence has been transformed into i ddim yn  for a negative.

This discovery calls for a revision to my original hypothesis that to talk about oneself, you begin the sentence with Dw i'n.  It appears that in some sentences, just Dw i is used.

I also came upon the sentence, "Ywd, dw i eisiau cath.  Yes, I want a cat.  Perhaps dw i is used in negative sentences and questions? 

Dych chi'n hoffi Owen?  Do you like Owen?  We have discovered the subject and verb forms for "you" which are dych and chi'n.  

The pattern can now be used to ask other questions.

Dych chi eisiau dysgu Cymraeg.  Do you want to learn Welsh?

But here is another challenge to our hypothesis!  Compare Dych chi'n hoffi Owen?  (Do you like Owen?) to Dych chi eisiau dysgu Cymraeg ( Do you want to learn Welsh?).  The first sentence uses chi'n and the second uses chi (as is the case with the form for "I"). Why?  Is the answer structural or phonetic?  Could it be that the added i'n is needed before certain sounds, like the "h" of hoffi or the "y" of "yfed"?

Unfortunately, we don't know yet. Much patience is required at this point! We have to leave that question for the future until we find more examples to clear up the problem.  Or if new examples don't give us the definitive answer,  there are always grammar explanations to fall back on.

Oh, no, did I really say that?






 

Wednesday, January 25, 2017

Searching for Patterns in Language

Patterns



A rancorous argument continues to rage in the field of foreign language acquisition.  What, you haven't heard of the Great Grammar Debate? Traditionalists hold fast to their claim that grammar study must proceed acquisition of a new language.  Other language educators maintain that grammar study should be delayed until the learner knows enough of the new language to apply grammar information.  The Great Grammar Debate is a continuum, with methods and materials for foreign language study falling along a scale.

Because I adhere to the less grammar at the beginning contingent, when I began language study on Duolingo about four years ago,  I made a vow to use only sparingly the "Tips and Notes" (grammar information) provided by Duolingo.




 I wanted to challenge myself to work out the grammar of new languages in my own head.

As I began working with Spanish, then Portuguese, then French, I had no problem turning up my nose at grammar explanations.  To be fair, years of classroom study in these three languages had already given me a hefty dose of traditional grammar in each of them.  Then I decided to add Irish, Welsh and Romanian to my daily language study regimen. Instead of zipping through the Duolingo exercises in a few minutes, I found myself really having to concentrate and, heaven forbid, THINK!  

No traditional grammar explanations for me!  I was going to conduct my own mini-research in the new languages to discover grammatical patterns.  After all, as much as new languages may seem random to us, all language is rule based.  My job was to discover the rules. 



IRISH

Exercises with Irish prepositions were driving me crazy.  You see, Irish prepositions contain not only the preposition itself but also the object of the preposition, all within the same word.  For example, "in front of him" is expressed in Irish by the one word "roimhe." I was faced with the double task of translating the prepositions, which seem to take on unexpected meanings in Irish, with the more mundane task of recognizing the person referred to. As I wrote down sentences containing prepositions and their English translations, a pattern began to emerge.

Tá fáilte romhainn. We are welcome.

Tá muinín ag an múnteoir asainn.  The teacher has trust in us.

Conclusion:  the -asainn refers to the first person singular (we or us)

Baineann tú díot do hata.  You take your hat off.

Dlíodóir atá ionat.  You are a lawyer.

Conclusion:  the -t ending mark the second person singular (you).

Tá an ceapaire roimhe. The sandwich is in front of him.

Is as Éirinn di.  She is from Ireland.

Instead of comparison, contrast revealed an -e ending for third person singular masculine (he) and an -i ending for third person singular feminine -i (she), which is supported by the Irish words for he, sé, and she, sí. 

Finally, I am fairly confident that the ending for prepositions referring to third person plural (them) is -bh because Bainimid na madraí díobh   translates as "We take the dogs from them."

Unfortunately, I have yet to discover the pattern for prepositions referring to first person (I).  But isn't that the way natural language works?  We have no guarantee that normal conversation will provide us with every single grammar possibility.  I can be patient.

Are you still awake, reader?  Not everyone is quite as fascinated with the way languages are constructed as I am.  But for those of you who enjoy puzzles and codes, discovering grammatical patterns is a bit of fun and a great help in deciphering new languages.      






Thursday, December 29, 2016

Some fascinating grammar facts (yes, really!)


I recently added a sixth language to my daily study regimen on Duolingo.  I know; it's an obsession. But before I admit to being a bit quirky when it comes to language study, I would like to defend my choice to spend valuable time each day learning other languages. You see, I truly get a kick out of analyzing how other languages are put together.

Linguists will tell you that languages are more similar than they are different, and I agree.  The common elements of nouns, verbs, questions, and negatives come to mind.  But each language I study has differences in grammar that are important in the language acquisition process. 



First, let's explore up front why the word "grammar" gives some people the heebie-jeebies. I think it is because grammar in our native language (English for me) is fairly boring because we have already acquired it automatically. But once we start overlaying our English grammar patterns on new languages, ah! That's when grammar becomes intriguing. 




Let's take a look at a grammar point in Spanish labeled "The Personal A." Here is an example: Busco mi hotel (I am looking for my hotel); Busco a mi esposo (I am looking for my husband). Did you notice the extra "a" in the second sentence?  Don't bother trying to translate it. The personal a is a Spanish grammar requirement before direct object nouns that are specific people. Sounds easy enough, right?  But how about Bitsy, my beloved pet cat?  Isn't she as important as any person?  Yes! Busco a Bitsy.  I am looking for Bitsy.  Here is the link to a YouTube video that gives further explanation of the personal a in Spanish:    The Personal A . 





On to Portuguese, which may be my favorite other language.  Portuguese creates combined words that make beginning Portuguese students tear their hair out.  Take a simple phrase like "the girl's book" which translates into Portuguese "the book of the girl" (o livro da menina).  The English phrase has five words; the Portuguese phrase has four.  The Portuguese word da combines the meanings of "of" and "the." And the Portuguese language has many of these forms, which are usually prepositions combined with other parts of speech. Take a look here Chart of Portuguese combined forms to be completely overwhelmed by grammar rules. These forms are best acquired rather than learned!




Another of the languages I have studied for many years, French, still makes my mind work overtime with some unique grammar rules.  To say, "She remembered" in French, you have to know that "to remember" is a reflexive verb, that is, a reflexive pronoun is required.  Then the past tense of reflexive verbs in French is formed with the helping verb, être.  And if that isn't enough, the past participle must agree with the subject.  Elle s'est souvenue is the result. ( I missed this translation recently on Duolingo!) Not easy, but fascinating.

For the next blog post, I am planning to tackle some sticky grammar points in Irish, Welsh, and Romanian, all languages that are fairly new to me, and therefore even more of a challenge.

Recently I read the headline of an article that ran something like "Forget Luminosity; Learn a Language."  Analyzing grammar may just make those neurons in our brains a little more active.